local exporter is the default exporter in X-Pack monitoring. It routes data
back into the same (local) cluster. In other words, it uses the production
cluster as the monitoring cluster. For example:
This exporter exists to provide a convenient option when hardware is simply not available. It is also a way for developers to get an idea of what their actions do for pre-production clusters when they do not have the time or resources to provide a separate monitoring cluster. However, this exporter has disadvantages that impact the local cluster:
- All indexing impacts the local cluster and the nodes that hold the monitoring indices' shards.
- Most collectors run on the elected master node. Therefore most indexing occurs with the elected master node as the coordinating node, which is a bad practice.
- Any usage of X-Pack monitoring for Kibana uses the local cluster’s resources for searches and aggregations, which means that they might not be available for non-monitoring tasks.
- If the local cluster goes down, the monitoring cluster has inherently gone down with it (and vice versa), which generally defeats the purpose of monitoring.
local exporter, all setup occurs only on the elected master node. This
means that if you do not see any monitoring templates or ingest pipelines, the
elected master node is having issues or it is not configured in the same way.
http exporter, the
local exporter has the advantage of accessing
the monitoring cluster’s up-to-date cluster state. It can therefore always check
that the templates and ingest pipelines exist without a performance penalty. If
the elected master node encounters errors while trying to create the monitoring
resources, it logs errors, ignores that collection, and tries again after the
The elected master node is the only node to set up resources for the
exporter. Therefore all other nodes wait for the resources to be set up before
indexing any monitoring data from their own collectors. Each of these nodes logs
a message indicating that they are waiting for the resources to be set up.
One benefit of the
local exporter is that it lives within the cluster and
therefore no extra configuration is required when the cluster is secured with
X-Pack security. All operations, including indexing operations, that occur from a
local exporter make use of the internal transport mechanisms within Elasticsearch. This
behavior enables the exporter to be used without providing any user credentials
when X-Pack security is enabled.
One feature of the
local exporter, which is not present in the
is a cleaner service. The cleaner service runs once per day at 01:00 AM UTC on
the elected master node.
The role of the cleaner service is to clean, or curate, the monitoring indices
that are older than a configurable amount of time (the default is
cleaner exists as part of the
local exporter as a safety mechanism. The
exporter does not make use of it because it could enable a single misconfigured
node to prematurely curate data from other production clusters that share the
same monitoring cluster.
In a dedicated monitoring cluster, the cleaning service can be used without having to also monitor the monitoring cluster. For example: